Leading Through Change with Confidence
Leadership transitions test even the strongest nonprofit teams. Whether your Executive Director just announced retirement or a sudden resignation left the board scrambling, change at the top can shake confidence across the entire organization.
In recent years, nonprofit leadership turnover has reached record highs—driven by burnout, post-pandemic restructuring, and shifting priorities. Boards across the country are asking the same question:
How do we keep our mission moving forward while we find the right next leader?
That’s where interim nonprofit leadership comes in.
Interim leaders bridge the gap between “what was” and “what’s next.” They stabilize the organization, restore clarity, and give boards time to make the right long-term decision. Done well, interim leadership doesn’t just protect your mission—it strengthens it.
What Is Interim Nonprofit Leadership?
An interim leader steps into a nonprofit’s top role—such as CEO, Executive Director, or Chief Development Officer—for a defined period, typically six to eighteen months.
Unlike a consultant or advisor, interim leaders are hands-on executives. They manage daily operations, support staff, assess systems, and ensure the organization remains steady through change.
At Raise the Bar Consulting, we view interim leadership as more than a stopgap—it’s an intentional season of assessment, alignment, and growth. Our interim executives bring neutrality, structure, and deep nonprofit experience to guide organizations through complex transitions with confidence and care.
And interim leadership isn’t only for moments of crisis or turnover. Many growing nonprofits find themselves ready to professionalize after years of volunteer-led operations. That was the case for Boost a Foster Family, an inspiring Arizona organization that had been run entirely by volunteers since its founding. As demand for their services expanded, they partnered with Raise the Bar Consulting to bring on their first paid interim Executive Director. Together, we’re building the structure, systems, and leadership capacity that will allow the next permanent leader to step into a strong and sustainable organization.
Whether you’re facing sudden change or preparing for growth, interim leadership provides the bridge to what’s next.
5 Signs Your Nonprofit Is Ready for Interim Leadership
1. A Sudden Executive Departure
When change happens fast, experience matters even more.
Unexpected leadership exits—whether due to resignation, termination, or loss—can disrupt operations and morale. An interim leader quickly steps in to maintain continuity, guide staff, and give the board time to recruit the right permanent successor without rushing the process.
2. Transition or Uncertainty
Even planned departures create a gap that needs steady hands.
When a long-serving executive retires or transitions out, staff often feel the loss of direction. An interim leader keeps the organization focused, mentors the team, and ensures a seamless handoff to new leadership—preserving both progress and morale.
3. The Need for Organizational Change
Turnover often reveals what’s already been simmering beneath the surface.
Sometimes leadership transitions expose deeper challenges—misaligned strategy, unclear roles, outdated systems, or culture shifts. Interim leaders serve as objective change agents, helping boards assess what’s working, identify barriers, and lay the groundwork for long-term organizational health before a new executive steps in.
4. Periods of Rapid Growth or Major Shifts
Growth without systems can strain even the best teams.
When new funding, partnerships, or mergers dramatically change a nonprofit’s size or scope, existing structures can quickly fall behind. Interim leaders bring the strategic oversight and systems thinking needed to strengthen infrastructure, manage risk, and sustain momentum through change.
This also applies to organizations evolving from volunteer-driven efforts to more formal operations. A skilled interim executive can design the structure, staffing, and strategy needed to ensure a smooth transition into a new stage of maturity.
5. Internal Conflict or Low Morale
Sometimes a fresh, neutral perspective makes all the difference.
If tension exists between the board and staff—or among leadership—an interim leader can serve as a trusted bridge. They help reestablish trust, clarify decision-making, and align everyone around mission and outcomes. With neutrality and care, they create a healthier foundation for your next permanent leader to thrive.
Why Interim Leadership Is Rising in Demand
Nonprofit leadership turnover has reached unprecedented levels nationwide. According to BoardSource and the Chronicle of Philanthropy, as many as 45–50% of nonprofits anticipate a leadership change within the next five years.
At the same time, expectations on nonprofit executives have never been higher. Fundraising pressures, evolving community needs, and post-pandemic recovery have left many leaders stretched thin.
Interim leadership offers a strategic solution—giving organizations breathing room to reset, refocus, and rebuild before making their next major hire.
“Interim leadership isn’t just about holding the seat—it’s about holding the mission steady.”
— Jennifer Tersigni, Raise the Bar Consulting
How Interim Leadership Supports Lasting Change
Effective interim leaders do far more than “keep the lights on.” They:
-
Stabilize operations and rebuild team confidence
-
Assess and strengthen systems and processes
-
Support boards through strategic decisions
-
Guide the hiring and onboarding of new leadership
-
Rebuild donor and stakeholder trust
-
Help volunteer-driven organizations professionalize operations for long-term sustainability
By approaching transition through an equity and sustainability lens, they ensure that staff, programs, and culture remain strong long after their term ends.
At Raise the Bar Consulting, we take a holistic approach—balancing the practical needs of day-to-day leadership with the strategic foresight required for long-term success.
Partnering for Stability and Growth
For more than fifteen years, Raise the Bar Consulting has supported nonprofits through leadership transitions—providing interim CEOs, COOs, and Chief Development Officers who bring calm, credibility, and measurable results.
Every organization’s story is different. Whether you’re facing a sudden change, navigating rapid growth, or transitioning from volunteer leadership to your first paid executive role, our team helps you move forward with clarity and care.
Learn More: Explore our Transitional Leadership Solutions
Get Started: Book a free consultation with Jennifer →
Final Thought
Leadership change doesn’t have to disrupt your mission—it can strengthen it.
When guided with intention, interim nonprofit leadership becomes a bridge to a more sustainable, resilient, and aligned future.
Recent Comments